Lubombo Home Background OverviewSpatial SupportProgress

Intervention Assessment

Intervention Assessment

A separate Intervention Assessment protocol has been drawn up to measure the success or failure of the intervention at specific times.  Indicators include entomological, parasitological, disease incidence and economic variables as well as community perceptions. Assessment and monitoring of these parameters are carried out before, during and after spraying intervention.

The effectiveness of the malaria control programme in the long-term will be assessed by the incidence of malaria over time in Mozambique as well as in the neighbouring malarious areas of South Africa and Swaziland. The success will not only be measured using process (e.g. spraying coverage) and biological markers (e.g. parasite prevalence rates, health facility patient numbers and mosquito vector reductions), but by assessing the effects on tourism using tourist facility occupancy rates, job creation and malaria risk perceptions, in all three countries over the course of the period 2000 to 2005.

A full assessment of the effects of the intervention strategy, based on scientific principles, will be carried out to to evaluate the programme's efficacy, to enable fine tuning of control, and to document cost and effectiveness, data vital to other programmes in the malarious areas of the continent.  Indicators for the Intervention Assessment will include parasite index, disease incidence, morbidity and mortality, mosquito abundance, mosquito species composition both before and following control.

The effective implementation of this 5 year project as well as its assessment relies on accurate malaria case information which will be housed in the Health Information System of the Ministry of Health in Mozambique and the MRC in Durban. Case management capability at health facilities in the study areas will be upgraded through a nurses training programme and an adequate supply of anti-malarial drugs. The Health Information System will further be upgraded on an ongoing basis towards allowing evaluation of intervention measures. Data on malaria morbidity and mortality will be accessed from the hospitals and clinics.

Vector Assessment

This includes measurement of vector density, species identity, distribution, behaviour, infectivity, survival rate and susceptibility to insecticide under use. Traps to catch mosquitoes exiting from houses were fitted to homes at 14 sentinel sites in Mozambique. These are cleared daily by the homeowners and the mosquitoes preserved in labeled and dated containers for analysis.

The sentinel sites are:

Zone 1: Bela Vista, Boane, Catuane, Changalane, Namaacha ,  Salamanga, Ponto do ouro, Zitundo.
Zone 1A: Matola Rio, Matola C, Catembe, Beluluane 24, Beluluane A, Mussumbuluco
Zone 2: Sabie, Ressano Garcia, Faztene, Moamba, Batelao
Zone 3: Motaze, Chicutso - Manjangue, Magude Sede, Mapulanguene, Panjane, Maguiguane, Mawadla, Mawandlha, Chicutso Sede, Chobela

Quality of spraying and the duration of insecticide  activity are measured using bioassays.  The latter are carried out on a monthly basis by personnel from the Mocambican Ministry of Health in collaboration with scientists from Mpumalanga  and the MRC for five days per month over a period of 6 months.    ( see baseline survey )

Prevalence Assessment

Pre- and post-intervention parasite prevalence and levels of morbidity and mortality are assessed using clinic data and cross sectional parasite surveys prior to and after spraying. ( see baseline survey ) Parasite prevalence surveys are undertaken each year in June at the sentinel sites to evaluate the efficacy of the intervention.

Malaria Information Systems

The effectiveness of the malaria control programme in the longterm will be assessed by the incidence of the disease over time in Mozambique as well as in the neighbouring malarious areas of South Africa and Swaziland. Malaria Information Systems (MIS) were developed and implemented for the partner-sectors, based on the input and output requirements of each, in order to collect current as well as historical data.  This will indicate the trends both within each country and across the region, and allow an evaluation of the effectiveness of the spraying programme.

Initially, only hospital admissions of malaria were notifiable in Mozambique. However, by the end of 2001, all cases of malaria, both confirmed and suspected, were captured within the Mozambique Health Information System on a weekly basis.  Each health facility is currently required to send monthly malaria reports on suspected and confirmed cases to the District Directorate of Health which collates the district information. They are then sent to the Provincial Directorate of Health which collates these data for the Province and submits them to the Planning and Co-operation Department within the Ministry of Health.

Definitive diagnosis, previously only available at hospitals, is being phased in at clinics in Maputo province which will allow accurate malaria incidence data for the region.

While the individual regions will be responsible for the collection and analysis of their own data, the data for all regions of the SDI and this project more specifically, will be centrally collated and analysed in collaboration with the Malaria Research Programme of the Medical Research Council, SA.( see GIS component )

Malaria and Tourism

Indicators of the success of the malaria programme are not only measured using biological markers e.g. infection rates and mosquito vector reductions, but also by the effects on tourism e.g. bed occupancy, job creation and risk perceptions, in all 3 countries.

Studies in this regard are underway to assess the effect of malaria, both perceived and real, on local and international tourists, and the resulting impact on bed occupancy and job creation. Small geographic scale malaria risk maps have been produced in order to dispense appropriate malaria risk information to tourist facility owners, tourists and the media. A tourist information booklet dispensing appropriate information regarding prohylaxis in risk areas has been produced and released to tourism facilities. See Malaria and Tourism

The intervention assessment component of the project is being extended in collaboration with the Center for International Development of the Harvard Business School, USA, to evaluate both the micro and macro economic effects of malaria control. This will include monitoring household security (pre- and post-intervention) at a population level, time lost in industry due to malaria illness, and  the analysis of specific macro economic indicators.